The Sun run story claiming games make us ‘violent’ and ‘depressed’
The Sun, Britain’s top-selling newspaper, is running an article which has psychologist Steve Pope claiming that games are “addictive”, cause “depression” and are one of the main reasons why “we are getting more violent”.
Pope says players find it difficult to go about “their daily business” after “they spend all day killing people”. According to Pope, Modern Warfare appears to be the game that causes the most problems.
Amongst the evidence cited by Pope, is a claim that he was hired by a premier league football club to figure out why their players were incapable of winning an away football game. The diagnosis was that the players were playing video games on the journey to the match.
“Last year a premier league football club called me in to try to find out why the players weren’t playing well in away games. I found that on the coaches to the matches they were all playing computer games.”
It seems the solution to that age old problem, of football teams struggling to win away, is to stop the players from playing video games. With solutions such as this, Pope must be odds on favourite to be next manager at Manchester United once Sir Alex Ferguson retires. In light of this new evidence, PS3 Attitude believes that Rooney must be banned from playing video games otherwise England’s chances of winning the World Cup could be in jeopardy.
Pope later adds:
“One of the games causing many problems is the warfare series Call Of Duty. It is highly addictive and people play for hours on end. They spend all day killing people, then come off it and have to go about their daily business. I believe such games are one reason we are getting more violent.”
“I’ve got several patients who are what would be clinically termed addicted to… computer games. These things set the brain up for a pattern of gross fluctuation, too many highs and lows. For a short time, they can make people feel valued and boost their self-esteem. When they realise these feelings don’t last, some people – particularly youngsters – can become down, even having feelings of depression.”
It isn’t surprising to see an article such as this in the Sun, a tabloid famed for its sensationalism, but, worryingly, these negative stories are appearing with an alarming frequency. What is more concerning to gamers is that the industry has been getting little chance to defend itself.
Tim Ingham, editor of Computer and Video Games, was given a rare opportunity to defend the video games industry on national television on a popular talk show hosted by former gardener Alan Titchmarsh. The BAFTA awards for video games had made gaming a topic of discussion, but rather than celebrate the success of the industry, the opportunity was used to criticise gaming.
Ingham tried not to defend the violence, instead he attempted to educate parents about the age rating systems and the parental lock features on game consoles. He received a hostile reception from an audience that was more interested in what Julie Peasgood had to say. Peasgood, a previous winner of the Best Sex Writer Award from Scarlet Magazine for her book The Greatest Sex Tips in the World, labelled games as “racist” much to rapture of the audience. Check out the video above.
Can this negative perception of video games be changed? We hope so. We would be interested to hear your thoughts on the perception of gaming below…
[source]














Sadly sensationalism will always sell better than a balanced debate. It still doesn't stop it from being extremely frustrating.
I think we all had a similar facial expression to Tim Ingham, when first heard Alan Titchmarsh appear to suggest that violent films can only be seen at the cinema.
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
LikeWow, this kind of thing is so infuriating to watch. The only reason they make these panels so unbalanced is to draw a bigger reaction from the audience, which is obviously just good entertainment.
People always want to find the next big thing to blame for their issues, and in this case videogames are the scapegoat. It diverts responsibility away from them just so they can feel better about themselves. Ridiculous!
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
LikeI've sent off my complaint to ITV about it. Bearing in mind peasgood's comment about being against violence for entertainment- turns out she voice acted for a zombie game a few years ago. Ignorance!
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
LikeJust watched the video. Absolutely hilarious.
What was the CVG guy thinking that he's have the remotest chance of getting a light year within an intelligent debate?
What a complete bunch of nutters - including the audience.
It could have easily been mistaken for a dining room scene in Fawlty Towers or a Monty python sketch!
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
LikeWhat depresses and angers me is the violence, atrocities and oppression carried out in the name of one faith or another.
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
LikeGames do quite the opposite than making me depressed, it's one of the things I most enjoy - they are basically my life!
It seems like this is a very popular topic at the moment, although I hadn't really read too much about it until that show on ITV. I felt that show was just a way for the parents to shift the blame onto someone else.
It's their responsibility to control what their children play, if they think something is inappropriate don't buy it. But no, having a rating system and the internet at your finger tips to find the information as to whether a game is okay for your child to play isn't good enough - they want everyone else to suffer as consequence.
The people with this mindset, I find, are also determined to keep this idea and this view. No one else can be right or there is no middle line. The man on the ITV show even suggesting family games they jeered him, and almost mocked him.
It is also quite worrying to see many countries introducing bans for games at a certain level - I just hope it doesn't start to happen here.
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
LikeWhen will people realize that we have not become any more violent than before, we've become globalized, so that means when a crazy guy shoots up a school in nowhereland, the entire world hears about it. Do they really think that a chinese guy cutting off the head of someone a thousand years ago would ever reach the ears of someone in England who would then proceed with "Oh those japanese fellows are so violent, it must be because they play too many violent sports" sip his tea and have a good chuckle? No matter how much you want to convince yourself that you have scientific proof that kids get violent from games, you don't you moron. Such an idea is redicilous and i feel ashamed that there are reporters, scientists and people actually believing that. Sure it's in the human nature to be afraid of what they don't understand, but get your face out of your f*****g ass.... /rant
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
Like